Whereas Fresh York congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and nationwide progressives decry corporate money in politics, Governor Andrew Cuomo has embraced the extremely unethical observe of soliciting marketing and marketing campaign money from yelp contractors.
Our auditors at OpenTheBooks.com discovered 347 yelp vendors that gave $6.2 million in political donations to Cuomo over a six-year duration (2014-2019). In the meantime, these corporations reaped $7 billion in yelp payments.
These donations represented the identical of upper than half of of the present money readily on hand – $11.9 million – in the governor’s marketing and marketing campaign committee as of 12/31/2019, based totally on disclosures.
We created an interactive scheme displaying by ZIP Code all of the governor’s marketing and marketing campaign contributions since 2014. Appropriate click a pin (ZIP Code) and scroll appropriate down to see the outcomes that render in the chart beneath the scheme.
We reached out to Governor Cuomo and Rich Azzopardi, a senior advisor, answered for the administration, “No contribution of any dimension plays a characteristic in any legitimate action and any legitimate who might also be swayed by a single buck has no commercial being in authorities.”
However, since 1940, folks and entities negotiating or working under federal contracts had been prohibited from giving political money to federal candidates, parties, or committees. In Fresh York, however, this political patronage is perfectly appropriate (no no longer as much as for now).
Listed below are one of the considerable sizable winners who gave marketing and marketing campaign money to Gov. Cuomo and one at a time obtained yelp payments.
Hospitals – Covid-Particular Patients Transferred To Nursing Homes
The Increased Fresh York Successfully being facility Affiliation (Affiliation) funneled $1 million to Cuomo’s re-election thru the yelp Democratic score collectively in 2018. That same year, the Affiliation and the healthcare union, 1199SEIU, backed Cuomo’s healthcare “reforms” and spent $5.9 million lobbying in Albany.
By February 2020, Cuomo appointed the Affiliation’s past chair and board member Michael Dowling alongside with 1199SEIU President Dennis Rivera as co-chairmen of the “Medicaid Redesign Group.” (Deliver Medicaid became $4 billion in the red thanks to Cuomo’s accounting gimmicks.)
Appropriate six weeks ahead of the governor’s appointment, Michael Dowling gave Cuomo a $5,000 marketing and marketing campaign donation (12/14/19). (Dowling is additionally the CEO of Northwell Successfully being – which obtained $10 million in yelp payments in 2019.)
Twenty-eight days ahead of the governor made 1199SEIU president Dennis Rivera co-chairman of his Medicaid Group, the union gave $15,000 to Cuomo’s re-election fund (1/6/2020). Since 2014, 1199SEIU backed Cuomo with political endorsements and $95,250 in marketing and marketing campaign money.
Then, the pandemic hit. The Affiliation and Cuomo’s healthcare energy brokers/predominant marketing and marketing campaign donors happy the administration to transfer obvious Covid-19 patients to nursing homes to relieve bed pressures on hospitals.
An estimated 15,000 senior residents died in Fresh York nursing homes even while the scientific institution association ran statewide marketing selling Cuomo and the safety of hospitals.
Real Property, Lisp, and Construction Companies
Between years 2011 and 2020, genuine property tycoon Scott Rechler, proprietor of RXR Realty, LLC, his wife, young folks, and affiliated LLC corporations gave $540,000 to Cuomo’s marketing and marketing campaign fund. Family donations amounted to $385,000 and more than one LLCs funded one other $155,000.
Scott’s brother, Todd, Chief Construction and Lisp Officer at RXR Realty, additionally contributed a additional $90,000 to Cuomo at some stage in the duration.
We discovered four genuine property leases owned by RXR Realty affiliated LLCs and signed by two yelp companies: Office of Inspector Overall and Commission on Judicial Behavior. These leases had been signed in the years 2014, 2019, and 2020 and are worth $41 million with $13.7 million already paid out. (Set aside: In 2014, RXR bought the building and the yelp companies had been existing tenants.)
The public has a simply to understand whether Cuomo became serving the public interest or his personal political interest when his administration negotiated these leases. Each transaction is a possible struggle of interest.
Furthermore, in 2011, the governor appointed Rechler to the Board of the Port Authority of Fresh York and Fresh Jersey, the attach he turned chairman. In 2017, the governor nominated Rechler to the Board of the Metropolitan Transit Authority (MTA) and he served except 2019.
Right here’s one other example:
CHA Consulting, Inc., based as Clough, Harbour & Mates, gave Cuomo $195,000 between 2013-2015. One by one, yelp data exhibit the agency obtained 47 yelp contracts for $134.7 million with $63.1 million already spent. We discovered $14 million in contracts given to the agency within 365 days of the selling and marketing campaign contributions.
Responding to our comment request, Michael Platt, Overall Counsel and Govt Vice President of CHA Consulting diagram back the assertion:
“CHA Consulting, Inc. has been offering high quality engineering products and companies to the Deliver of Fresh York for higher than 50 years. CHA has no longer made any marketing and marketing campaign contributions to Governor Cuomo since 2015. Any depiction that CHA is receiving work from the Deliver of Fresh York thanks to marketing and marketing campaign contributions is incorrect and incorrect.”
Extensive Four Accounting Firms – $360,000 in marketing and marketing campaign money
The self sustaining accounting corporations, Deloitte; Ernst & Younger (EY); KPMG; and PriceWaterhouseCooper collectively gave Gov. Cuomo $360,000 in marketing and marketing campaign donations at some stage in years 2014-2019. The corporations reaped $258.8 million in yelp payments.
Between 2013 and 2015, Fresh York regulatory companies and the governor investigated Deloitte, PwC, and EY for alleged wrongdoing. The corporations paid $45 million and varied penalties to settle the many claims.
Are these corporations “self sustaining” auditors with a fiduciary responsibility to taxpayers? We discovered that the corporations coordinated their marketing and marketing campaign money to the governor giving the same portions on the same days in the same years.
Three of the Extensive Four – PwC, KPMG, and EY – every gave the genuine same amount of marketing and marketing campaign money to Cuomo at some stage in the six-year duration ($88,333.33). Deloitte contributed one other $105,000.
Even in Illinois, the attach the number-one manufactured product is corruption, a 2011 laws barred yelp vendors with contracts exceeding $50,000 from giving marketing and marketing campaign donations to statewide officeholders.
Fresh York has no fashioned ban on politicians soliciting yelp vendors for marketing and marketing campaign money.
Extensive Banks – $196,100 in marketing and marketing campaign money
Citibank – As Authorized legitimate Overall of Fresh York, Andrew Cuomo compelled Citibank to fund a $2 million pupil mortgage education fund administered by his position of job, threatened lawsuits over “free” checking, and alongside with the Securities and Alternate Commission, compelled a $7.3 billion repurchase of allegedly fallacious auction-fee securities.
Alternatively, since 2014, Citibank donated $70,000 to the governor’s marketing and marketing campaign fund and cleared $2.9 billion in yelp payments. Citi is the supplier for the yelp’s profitable decide and shuttle card commercial – a $4 billion contract spanning seven years except 2021.
Financial institution of The United States
However, since 2014, BofA gave $81,600 in marketing and marketing campaign money to Cuomo and reaped $11.5 million in yelp payments. Today, BofA is the issuer in the relief of the profitable Fresh York Shrimp one Make stronger Debt Card.
JPMorgan Creep – JPMorgan Creep & Co
Extensive Attorneys – high 10 corporations donate $440,000 in marketing and marketing campaign money
We discovered ten laws corporations that reaped $10.4 million in yelp payments after giving $440,000 in marketing and marketing campaign money to the governor, all since 2014. These donations came correct now from laws agency accounts and did no longer consist of principals, companions, or key workers (unless renowned).
Whiteman Osterman & Hanna obtained $3.3 million in yelp payments since 2014. The agency donated $13,750 to the governor’s marketing and marketing campaign.
At some stage in this duration, the agency inked eighteen contracts from twelve yelp companies alongside side seven contracts with states colleges connected to immigration appropriate work.
In 2016, WHO Authorities Alternate ideas (WHO), the lobbying arm of the laws agency, represented Louis Ciminelli, a sizable Cuomo donor and developer – in the shatter convicted in the “Buffalo Billion” scandal.
Nixon Peabody donated $83,635 to the governor’s marketing and marketing campaign fund. One by one, the agency obtained $2.2 million in contracts for correct work. When alongside side donations from companions and workers since 2010, donations to Cuomo complete $164,000.
Abrams Fensterman gave $25,129 in marketing and marketing campaign donations to the governor. One by one, the agency restful $1.75 million in yelp payments. In 2011, Cuomo appointed managing companion Howard Fensterman to the Public Successfully being and Successfully being Planning Council. In 2014, across the time when Fensterman’s privately owned nursing homes had been investigated, he gave $10,000 more to Cuomo’s marketing and marketing campaign.
Barclay Damon gave $55,000 in marketing and marketing campaign donations to the governor. One by one, the agency reaped $1.9 million in yelp payments. The agency diminished in dimension for $1 million to tackle the St. Regis Mohawk land claims thru the NY Division of Deliver. Will Barclay, companion, is additionally the minority chief in the Overall Assembly.
Orrick Herrington & Sutcliffe donated $5,000 to Cuomo and obtained $568,019 in yelp payments. Since 2011, the agency procured five contracts for a complete rate of $2.7 million. (Two more contracts flowed thru the Comptroller, a separate yelp officer, for $3.3 million.)
Others famed corporations backing the governor and receiving yelp payments integrated: Boies Schiller & Flexner ($100,000); Phillips Lytle ($93,500); Jackson Lewis ($51,500); Manatt, Phelps & Phillips ($17,500); and Winston & Strawn ($5,000).
Cable and Telco Companies — $610,000 in marketing and marketing campaign donations
In extremely regulated industries, these five predominant cable and phone corporations reaped $233.9 million in yelp payments since 2014.
Time Warner gave $75,000 in marketing and marketing campaign donations to the governor and, one at a time, obtained $52.9 million in yelp payments. Since 2014, the company procured $82.5 million in yelp contracts with the excellent in September 2019 – $49 million to present teleconnectivity products and companies.
AT&T gave $106,650 in marketing and marketing campaign donations to the governor while reaping $37.7 million in yelp payments between 2014 and 2019. Since 2014, contracts consist of $44 million and $48 million for statewide umbrella coverage and telecommunication products and companies.
Cablevision and its affiliate CSC Holdings collectively gave $155,000 and obtained $2.4 million in yelp payments. Owned by the Dolan family, they additionally had considerable tax breaks on their possession of Madison Sq. Backyard.
The Dolans, who additionally have the Fresh York Rangers and Knicks, gave person donations of $135,000 to Cuomo since 2014. With the sale of Cablevision to Altice Media Alternate ideas in 2016, donations to the governor by Cablevision Systems NY PAC stopped.
LLC Loophole — $12.6 million in marketing and marketing campaign money
Since 2014, Cuomo solicited marketing and marketing campaign money from 1,225 person limited liability corporations (LLCs) to elevate $12.6 million. Till January 31, 2019, when laws in the shatter closed the loophole, LLCs skirted the Fresh York marketing and marketing campaign finance laws limiting corporate political donations to $5,000.
Fully $1 in every $5 Cuomo raised between 2014 and 2019 flowed thru this loophole.
However, the 2019 legislative reforms did no longer discontinuance legitimate partnerships (LLPs) from exceeding the $5,000 corporate restrict. As an example, tremendous chunks of marketing and marketing campaign money continued to drift from laws corporations equivalent to Nixon, Peabody LLP ($40,000); Belluck & Fox LLP ($40,000); Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP ($25,000) and others between 2019 and the essential half of of 2020.
In the total examples identified above, no quid-legitimate-quo is alleged or implied; however, the patterns are troubling. Genuinely, the person transactions are doubtlessly appropriate at arm’s dimension.
However that’s precisely the topic. Politicians preside over, in essence, a legalized money-recycling plot geared toward monetizing incumbent political energy.
Cuomo didn’t reply our demand as to whether soliciting yelp contractors for marketing and marketing campaign money became ethical, and a senior aide, Rich Azzopardi, argued that the governor exerted no affect.
“Agency contracting is performed on the agency level on the merits, by profession civil servants and procurement consultants — without a enter or affect from the Govt Chamber—and on the total thru a competitive bidding route of.”
In the meantime, Fresh York residents are left with skyrocketing taxes and an increasingly more bleak future.
We are in a position to blame Governor Cuomo, however he’s ethical a mirrored image of this day’s damaged culture of public carrier.
Methodology: We matched corporations donating to Andrew Cuomo For Fresh York, Inc., as disclosed by the NYS Board of Elections, to yelp price transactions – which might perhaps be on hand for safe on the NYS Comptroller’s online page, Originate E-book Fresh York. One by one, the Comptroller posts a searchable contract file additionally within the Originate E-book Fresh York portal. To the extent that the details contains authorities errors, our portray will reproduce those errors. No quid legitimate quo or illegal task by any elected legitimate, company or person referenced on this piece is implied or supposed. Andrew Cuomo became elected governor in 2010. Every one or entity on this piece became given a possibility to present comment.